|
|
The web's most comprehensive resource on securitization |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Detailed
contents of
Vinod Kothari's Securitisation book Sept 2003 edition
Part I: Securitisation: Concept and Markets
CHAPTER 1: SECURITISATION AND STRUCTURED FINANCE... .29 Basic meaning of securitisation:..................................................................... 30Asset securitisation: What is an asset-backed security?.................................................................. 32 Legal preference by isolation:............................................................................ 34 Capital market window:...................................................................................... 35 Use of special purpose vehicles:....................................................................... 35 Some definitions of securitisation:...................................................... 36 Securitisation of receivables:........................................................................ 37 Quick guide to jargon:................................................................................. 37 Securitisation and structured finance:............................................................ 40 Some quick features of securitisation:........................................................... 40 What receivables are securitisable:.................................................... 40 Creation of security:.......................................................................... 41 Special purpose vehicle:.................................................................... 42 Re-distribution of risks:..................................................................... 43 Rating.............................................................................................. 43 The Big picture of securitisation of finance:................................................... 44 Changing structure of financial markets:............................................. 44 Institutionalisation of savings:............................................................................. 44 Changes in corporate borrowing:..................................................................... 45 Securitisation and disintermediation:................................................................ 46 Changes in bank liability structure.................................................................... 47 Securitisation: changing the face of banking:............................................... 47 Capital markets fuelled securitisation:............................................................. 48 Securitisation and financial disintermediation:..................................... 49 Utilities added by financial intermediaries:..................................................... 49 Securitisation: changes the function of intermediation:.............................. 50 Securitisation as a tool of risk management:.................................................. 51 Securitisation and credit derivatives:............................................................... 52 Synthetic securitisation:......................................................................................... 52 Economic impact of securitisation:................................................................ 53 1. Facilitates creation of markets in financial claims:........................... 53 2. Disperses holding of financial assets:.............................................. 53 3. Promotes savings:......................................................................... 54 4. Reduces costs:............................................................................. 54 5. Diversifies risks:............................................................................ 54 6. Focuses on use of resources, and not their ownership:................... 55 7. Smoothens impact of recession:.................................................... 55 The alchemy of securitisation: is the sum of parts more than the whole?........ 55 The alchemy of structured finance:..................................................... 56 Structured finance:.................................................................................................. 56 Lower costs due to higher leverage................................................................. 57 Capturing scale and volume efficiencies......................................................... 58 Risks and benefits of securitisation:............................................................... 58 Abdication of credit: Subprime lending created and sold:...................... 60 Trading on thin capital:.......................................................................................... 61 Off balance sheet financing:............................................................................... 62 Increases opacity of banks:................................................................................ 63 The case of Superior Bank................................................................................. 64 Cross-sector risk transfers:................................................................................. 65 Monetary policy sterilised:.................................................................................. 65 chapter 2: SECURITISATION : METHODOLOY AND STRUCTURES 67 Modus-operandi of securitisation briefly explained....................................... 68 Features of securitisation of receivables:....................................................... 71 1. Mode of asset-based financing:..................................................... 71 2. Mode of structured financing:........................................................ 72 3. Securitisation of claims against third parties:................................... 73 4. Limited Recourse:......................................................................... 73 5 Asset features:............................................................................... 74 1. Asset should represent cashflows:.............................................................. 75 2. Quality of the receivables:.............................................................................. 75 3. Diversification of the portfolio:..................................................................... 76 4. Size of individual receivable:......................................................................... 76 5. Maturity composition of the receivables:.................................................. 77 6. Periodicity of payments:.................................................................................. 77 7. Homogeneity of the assets:............................................................................ 77 8. No executory clauses:..................................................................................... 77 9. Capacity to assign:............................................................................................ 78 10. Independence from the originator:........................................................... 78 11. Assets should be free of withholding taxes/ pre-paid taxes:.......... 78 6 Originator features:........................................................................ 78 1. Receivables as major assets:......................................................................... 78 2. Financial and organisational strength:......................................................... 80 7 Issuer/ SPV features:..................................................................... 80 8 Investor features............................................................................ 81 Securitisation and factoring:.......................................................................... 82 Securitisation and ring fencing:...................................................................... 82 Asset classes:.............................................................................................. 83 Broad types of securitisation structures:........................................................ 85 Cash versus synthetic structures:....................................................... 87 True sale versus secured loan structures:........................................... 87 Pass-through versus collateral structure:............................................ 88 Discrete trust versus master trust:...................................................... 88 Direct portfolio transfers:............................................................................. 89 Pass-through structure................................................................................. 91 Steps in a pass through transaction.................................................................. 91 Nature of pass through certificates:................................................................. 92 Difficulties in the pass through structure:........................................................ 93 Refinements in the pass through structure:.................................................... 94 Pay-through structure:....................................................................... 95 Collateralised mortgage obligation bonds:.......................................... 99 Refinements in CMO structure:....................................................................... 101 Revolving assets securitisation:........................................................ 103 Future flows securitisation:.............................................................. 104 Advantages of securitisation for the issuer................................................... 112 Lower cost............................................................................................................. 112 Alternative investor base.................................................................................... 113 Perfect matching of assets and liabilities...................................................... 113 Makes the issuer-rating irrelevant.................................................................. 113 Multiplies asset creation ability:....................................................................... 114 Allows higher funding:......................................................................................... 114 Off-balance sheet financing:.............................................................................. 114 Helps in capital adequacy requirements:...................................................... 115 Improves capital structure................................................................................. 115 Better opportunity of trading on equity with no increased risk:.......... 115 Extends credit pool:............................................................................................. 116 Not regulated as a loan:..................................................................................... 116 Reduces credit concentration:.......................................................................... 116 Avoids interest rate risk:.................................................................................... 116 Arbitraging by repackaging:.............................................................................. 116 Arbitraging on liquidity and term structure:................................................. 117 Improves accounting profits.......................................................... 117 Advantages to the investors:....................................................................... 117 1. Better Security:............................................................................................ 118 2. Good ratings:................................................................................................ 118 3. Rating resilience:.......................................................................................... 118 4. Better matching with investment objectives:..................................... 118 5. Good spreads:.............................................................................................. 119 6. Few instances of default:.......................................................................... 119 7. Moral responsibility:................................................................................... 119 8. Better matching with investment objectives:..................................... 119 Threats in securitisation:............................................................................. 119 1. Costly source:................................................................................................... 120 2. Uneconomical for lower requirements:................................................... 120 3. Passes on database to investors:............................................................... 120 4. Leaves the entity with junk assets:............................................................ 120 5. Poses liquidity threats:................................................................................... 121 6. Bad in bad days:.............................................................................................. 121 7. Makes profit accounting volatile................................................................ 121 Appendix Securitisation terminology............................. 123 chapter 3: The World of Securitisation.......................... 147 History of securitisation:............................................................................. 148 Deeper in history............................................................................ 149 The US mortgage market:............................................................... 149 Ginnie Mae's first securitisation initiative:..................................................... 150 Fannie Mae's securitisation deals:.................................................................. 150 The Freddie Mac:................................................................................................. 150 Spreads over to non-mortgage assets:............................................. 150 Securitisation through recession:...................................................... 151 The life cycle of securitisation:.................................................................... 151 Present state of securitisation:..................................................................... 152 North America.......................................................................................... 152 United States:................................................................................. 152 Canada:......................................................................................... 155 Europe:..................................................................................................... 155 Origins of European securitisation:................................................................. 156 Growth of securitisation in Europe:................................................................ 156 United Kingdom:............................................................................ 157 Legal Systems and initiatives:......................................................................... 158 Taxation:................................................................................................................. 158 Originator taxation:.................................................................. 159 Investors' taxation:................................................................... 159 SPV taxation:.......................................................................... 159 Accounting and regulatory treatment:........................................................... 160 SPV structures:...................................................................................................... 160 Germany:....................................................................................... 160 Pfandbriefe: The traditional German instrument:..................................... 160 Modern securitisation market.......................................................................... 161 German regulations on securitisations:.......................................................... 162 ABS definition......................................................................... 162 Capital requirements................................................................ 162 No cherry-picking of receivables............................................. 164 Notification to the debtor:........................................................ 164 Not applicable to revolving assets:........................................... 165 Tax aspects:............................................................................................................ 165 Accounting Aspects............................................................................................. 165 Italy:............................................................................................... 166 State of the market and developments:........................................................ 166 Legal initiatives to promote securitisation:................................................... 166 Taxation of securitisation:.................................................................................. 168 Denmark:....................................................................................... 168 The birthplace of securitisation:....................................................................... 168 Present state of the market:.............................................................................. 169 Legal initiatives to promote securitisation:................................................... 169 Netherlands:................................................................................... 169 General legal system:........................................................................................... 169 Exemption regulation for SPVs.................................................... 170 Taxation:................................................................................................................... 172 France:........................................................................................... 172 Legal initiatives:...................................................................................................... 172 The French FCC:................................................................................................. 173 Taxation issues:...................................................................................................... 174 Synthetic securitisation........................................................................................ 174 Belgium:......................................................................................... 174 Development and state of the Market:......................................................... 174 Legal initiatives:...................................................................................................... 175 General law on assignment of receivables:.................................................. 175 Basic conditions concerning the receivables.............................................. 176 Regulatory framework........................................................................................ 177 Prudential regulation............................................................................................ 178 Taxation:................................................................................................................... 178 Portugal:......................................................................................... 179 Spain:............................................................................................. 180 State of the Market:............................................................................................. 180 Legal initiatives:...................................................................................................... 181 Regulatory and accounting issues:.................................................................. 182 Sweden:......................................................................................... 183 Legal and regulatory framework:.................................................................... 183 Finland:.......................................................................................... 183 Legal system:.......................................................................................................... 184 Switzerland:.................................................................................... 184 Luxembourg................................................................................... 185 Turkey........................................................................................... 186 Latvia............................................................................................. 187 Poland........................................................................................... 188 Austria........................................................................................... 189 Czech Republic.............................................................................. 189 Hungary......................................................................................... 190 Central and South America:....................................................................... 190 Origins of securitisation in Latin America:........................................ 191 Mexico:.......................................................................................... 191 State of the Market:............................................................................................. 191 Legal initiatives:...................................................................................................... 192 Tax issues................................................................................... 193 Brazil:............................................................................................. 193 State of the Market:............................................................................................. 193 Legal initiatives to promote securitisation:................................................... 194 Taxation of securitisation:.................................................................................. 195 Future flows and Brazilian bankruptcy laws:.............................................. 195 Asia:......................................................................................................... 196 Japan:............................................................................................ 197 General Overview................................................................................................ 197 Recent Developments......................................................................................... 198 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 198 Mortgage Backed Loans................................................................................... 199 Aspects of Taxation............................................................................................. 199 Accounting Aspects............................................................................................. 199 Others....................................................................................................................... 200 Singapore....................................................................................... 200 General Overview................................................................................................ 200 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 201 Taxation Aspects.................................................................................................. 202 Mortgage Backed Securities............................................................................ 202 Hong Kong.................................................................................... 203 General Overview................................................................................................ 203 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 203 Accounting Aspects............................................................................................. 203 Taxation Aspects.................................................................................................. 204 Mortgage Backed Securities............................................................................ 204 Thailand......................................................................................... 205 General Overview................................................................................................ 205 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 205 Taxation Aspects.................................................................................................. 208 Mortgage Backed Securities............................................................................ 209 Indonesia....................................................................................... 210 General Overview................................................................................................ 210 Recent Development........................................................................................... 210 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 210 Taxation Aspects.................................................................................................. 211 Korea............................................................................................ 212 General Overview................................................................................................ 212 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 213 Peoples' Republic of China:............................................................ 214 General Overview................................................................................................ 214 Recent Developments......................................................................................... 215 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 215 Taiwan........................................................................................... 216 General Overview................................................................................................ 216 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 216 Taxation Aspects.................................................................................................. 217 Pakistan......................................................................................... 218 General Overview................................................................................................ 218 Recent Development........................................................................................... 218 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 219 Taxation Aspects.................................................................................................. 220 The Pacific:............................................................................................... 221 Australia......................................................................................... 221 General Overview....................................................................... 221 Recent developments.................................................................. 221 Legal aspects.............................................................................. 222 Mortgage backed market............................................................ 222 Aspects of taxation..................................................................... 222 Accounting aspects..................................................................... 223 New Zealand................................................................................. 223 General Overview................................................................................................ 223 Recent Developments......................................................................................... 223 Legal Aspects........................................................................................................ 224 Aspects of Taxation............................................................................................. 225 Accounting Aspects............................................................................................. 225 Securitisation in India................................................................................. 226 Trends in global securitisation:.................................................................... 226 1. Blurring distinction between structured finance and corporate finance:………………… 227 2. Increasing use of derivatives in securitisations:..................................... 227 3. Increasing risk securitisations...................................................................... 228 4. Equity into debt, and debt into equity:..................................................... 228 chapter 4: Structuring, credit enhancing and evaluating securitisation transactions Parties involved:........................................................................................ 229 Primary parties:.............................................................................. 230 Supportive agencies:....................................................................... 230 Steps in a securitisation transaction:............................................................ 231 Initial feasibility study:..................................................................... 231 Objective of the originator:............................................................................... 231 Legal feasibility:..................................................................................................... 232 Financial feasibility:............................................................................................... 233 Systems feasibility:................................................................................................ 233 Key appointments:.......................................................................... 233 Asset analysis and selection:............................................................ 233 Due diligence audit:......................................................................... 234 Determination of the structure:......................................................... 235 Credit enhancements:...................................................................... 236 Intervening reinvestments:............................................................... 236 Guaranteed reinvestment contracts:............................................................... 237 Reinvestments in buying fresh receivables:.................................................. 237 Reinvestment in other permissible collateral:.............................................. 237 Fixing the legal structure:................................................................. 237 Legal opinions................................................................................ 238 Rating............................................................................................ 238 Offer.............................................................................................. 239 Appointment of servicer/ administrator:........................................... 239 Servicer capabilities............................................................................................. 239 Post completion routines................................................................. 239 Ongoing reporting:.......................................................................... 239 Clean up call:.................................................................................. 240 Credit enhancements:................................................................................. 240 First loss, second and subsequent loss:............................................ 241 Internal and external credit enhancements:....................................... 242 Originator credit enhancements:...................................................... 242 Excess spread or profit:..................................................................................... 242 Cash collateral:...................................................................................................... 243 Overcollateralisation:........................................................................................... 244 Early amortisation triggers:................................................................................ 244 Structural credit enhancements:....................................................... 245 Junior / senior structure or tranched securitisation:.................................. 245 Third party credit enhancements:..................................................... 246 Letters of credit:.................................................................................................... 246 Related party guarantee:.................................................................................... 246 Monoline insurance:............................................................................................. 246 Pool insurance:....................................................................................................... 246 Liquidity enhancement .............................................................................. 246 Pay-down structure................................................................................... 247 Cashflow waterfall:......................................................................... 247 Sequential paydown:........................................................................................... 247 Pro-rata paydown:............................................................................................... 248 Fast-pay/ slow-pay structure:.......................................................................... 248 Financial evaluation of securitisation transactions:........................................ 249 Basic cash flows in securitisation:.................................................... 249 Weighted average maturity of securitisation:..................................... 250 Securitisation and borrowing options:.............................................. 251 IRR or NPV:.................................................................................. 252 Weighted average cost method:...................................................... 255 chapter 5: Rating of securitisation transactions... 259 Rating agency concerns............................................................................. 260 Asset quality:.......................................................................................................... 260 Solvency of the issuer:........................................................................................ 261 Perfection of legal structure.............................................................................. 261 Tax risks................................................................................................................... 261 Clean and prior title to the securitised portfolio:....................................... 262 Risk of set-off........................................................................................................ 262 Risk of prepayment.............................................................................................. 262 Executory contractual clauses:......................................................................... 263 Ratings of connected parties:........................................................................... 263 Servicer or administrator rating:...................................................................... 263 Sovereign risks:..................................................................................................... 263 The rating process:.................................................................................... 264 Review / presentation.......................................................................................... 264 Asset analysis......................................................................................................... 264 Transaction analysis............................................................................................. 264 Legal and tax.......................................................................................................... 265 Rating models............................................................................................ 265
Part II: Securitisation asset classes chapter 6: Residential mortgage-backed securitisation 269 Mortgage funding systems:......................................................................... 270 Government support to housing finance:..................................................... 271 Why secondary mortgage markets:............................................................ 271 Origin of the secondary mortgage markets:................................................. 273 The secondary mortgage market in the USA:................................... 273 Agency market:..................................................................................................... 273 The non-agency market..................................................................................... 274 Current size of the US RMBS market:............................................ 277 Conforming and non-conforming market:................................................... 278 Secondary mortgage market in other countries:................................ 279 Current size of the RMBS market in Europe:............................................ 280 RMBS in UK......................................................................................................... 281 Structuring of RMBS transactions:............................................................. 281 Structure of agency-backed securitisation:....................................... 281 Illustration of Fannie Mae MBS structure:.................................................. 281 Secondary market in agency MBS................................................................ 284 Structure of non-agency pass-throughs:........................................... 284 Structure of CMOs:........................................................................ 284 UK RMBS:.................................................................................... 285 Case study: Abbey National's Holmes Financing............................. 286 Special purpose vehicles:................................................................................... 288 The loan portfolio:................................................................................................ 288 Master trust and the transfer of assets:......................................................... 289 Home equity loans securitisation:................................................................ 291 Manufactured home loans:......................................................................... 292 European Mortgage bonds or Pfandbriefes:................................................ 293 Investing in the MBS market:..................................................................... 294 Who invests in MBS....................................................................... 294 Risks in investing in MBS:............................................................... 295 Orange County's bankruptcy:.......................................................................... 295 Askin Capital Management.............................................................................. 296 Beacon Hill Hedge fund:.................................................................................... 296 MBS versus fixed income investments:....................................................... 296 MBS and interest rates:...................................................................................... 298 Prepayment modeling in RMBS:..................................................... 298 Why do mortgagors prepay?........................................................................... 298 Relevance of prepayment modeling to investors:..................................... 299 Conditional prepayment rate:........................................................................... 300 How is the SMM information used to project yield:............................... 300 Need for a prepayment model:....................................................................... 300 The PSA prepayment model............................................................................ 301 Illustrations.............................................................................................................. 301 Projected speeds based on PSA:.................................................................. 301 Negative convexity of MBS:........................................................... 302 Illustration................................................................................................................ 302 Option-adjusted spread:.................................................................................... 305 chapter 7: Commercial mortgage-backed securitisation 307 What is CMBS......................................................................................... 308 Differences between RMBS and CMBS:........................................ 308 Typical features:............................................................................. 309 CMBS and REITs:......................................................................... 310 CMBS market:.......................................................................................... 311 Development of the CMBS market:................................................ 311 USA........................................................................................................................... 311 Late Development of CMBS market:.......................................................... 312 Reasons for decline post 1998 in the US market:................................... 312 Europe:..................................................................................................................... 314 Structure of a CMBS transaction:.............................................................. 314 Balance sheet and conduit activity:.................................................. 315 Trophy asset versus portfolio of assets:........................................... 315 By property sectors:....................................................................... 315 Balloon loans:................................................................................. 315 Diversification:................................................................................ 316 Spatial diversification:.......................................................................................... 316 Property-type diversification:........................................................................... 316 Servicers:....................................................................................... 316 Case study: GMAC's 2001-WTC transaction............................................ 316 Collateral:....................................................................................... 317 The loan:........................................................................................ 318 Prepayment protection....................................................................................... 320 The certificates:.............................................................................. 320 Retention of interests by the originator:........................................................ 321 Liquidity and credit enhancements:.................................................. 321 The aftermath:................................................................................ 321 Case study: Canary Wharf - A TYPICAL UK CMBS:.............................. 322 Introduction to the transaction:........................................................ 323 Transaction structure...................................................................... 323 The properties:............................................................................... 325 Cashflows...................................................................................... 326 Investing in CMBS.................................................................................... 326 Prepayment protection in CRE loans:.............................................. 327 Delinquency in CMBS:................................................................... 327 chapter 8: Credit cards securitisation:......................... 329 Nature of credit card debt......................................................................... 330 An overview of the market......................................................................... 331 Transaction structure................................................................................. 332 Revolving asset structure:................................................................ 333 Seller’s interest:.............................................................................. 333 Discrete and master trust structure:.................................................. 334 Allocation of interest:........................................................................................... 334 Allocation of principal and prepayments:.................................................... 334 Components of a credit card structure........................................................ 335 Portfolio yield:................................................................................ 335 Charge offs:.................................................................................... 337 Credit scores and the charge off rate:........................................................... 339 Payment rate:................................................................................. 339 Servicing fee and Base rate:............................................................ 339 Early amortization triggers:.............................................................. 340 Subordination structure in credit card ABS:..................................... 340 Investor experience in credit cards:............................................................ 341 Commercial Financial Services:....................................................... 341 NextCard:...................................................................................... 341 chapter 9: Auto loan securitisation................................ 343 Forms of car funding:................................................................................. 344 Auto loans securitisation market:................................................................ 344 The US market:.............................................................................. 345 Other countries:.............................................................................. 345 Collateral quality........................................................................................ 345 Typical structures:...................................................................................... 346 Credit enhancements:...................................................................... 346 Specific issues in auto loan securitisation..................................................... 347 Case study: Daimler-Chrysler Auto Trust:.................................................. 348 The collateral:................................................................................. 348 Transaction structure:...................................................................... 350 Issuer:........................................................................................................................ 351 Pay-down structure:............................................................................................ 351 Clean up call:.......................................................................................................... 351 Credit enhancements:...................................................................... 351 Over-collateralisation:......................................................................................... 351 Reserve fund:.......................................................................................................... 352 Yield supplement:................................................................................................. 352 Excess interest:...................................................................................................... 352 Certificates:............................................................................................................. 352 Cashflow waterfall:......................................................................... 352 chapter 10: Equipment Lease securitisation................. 355 Equipment leasing market:............................................................... 356 Equipment lease securitisation market:............................................. 356 Product structure............................................................................ 356 Rating of equipment lease securitisations:......................................... 357 Residual value risk in equipment lease securitisations:....................... 357 Investing in equipment lease securitisations:................................................. 358 chapter 11: Collateralised Debt Obligations............ 359 What is a CDO:........................................................................................ 360 Differences between CLOs and CBOs:........................................... 360 Typical structure of a CDO:............................................................ 361 Types of CDOs:........................................................................................ 361 Cash and synthetic CDOs:.............................................................. 362 CDO types based on collateral:...................................................... 362 Balance sheet and arbitrage CDOs:................................................. 363 Par value and market value based structures:................................... 363 Growth of the CDO market:...................................................................... 363 European CDO market.................................................................. 365 Balance sheet CDOs:................................................................................ 365 Traditional, cash CDOs:................................................................. 365 Type of SPV:......................................................................................................... 365 Underlying assets:................................................................................................. 365 Diversity score:...................................................................................................... 366 Reinvestment period:........................................................................................... 367 Typical stratification:............................................................................................ 367 Early amortisation triggers:................................................................................ 367 Structural tests:...................................................................................................... 368 Cashflow waterfall:............................................................................................... 368 Synthetic CDOs:............................................................................ 368 Arbitrage CDOs:....................................................................................... 368 Meaning of an arbitrage CDO:........................................................ 368 Illustration of arbitraging:................................................................. 369 Typical funding structure:................................................................................... 369 How and why arbitrage exists:........................................................................ 369 Emergence of arbitrage CDOs:....................................................... 370 Difference between arbitrage CDOs and balance sheet CDOs:........ 371 Revolving period:............................................................................ 372 Market value CDOs:................................................................................. 372 Structure of a market value CDO:................................................... 372 Liabilities of cashflow and market value CDOs:............................... 373 Ramp up period:........................................................................................ 374 The CDO manager:................................................................................... 374 Qualities of the CDO manager:....................................................... 375 Experience:.............................................................................................................. 375 Staffing:..................................................................................................................... 376 Strong internal controls:...................................................................................... 376 Technological investments:................................................................................ 376 Financial resources:.............................................................................................. 376 Balancing between equity investors and debt investors:....................... 379 The CDO manager’s fees:.............................................................. 380 The CDO investors:................................................................................... 380 The CDO trustee:...................................................................................... 381 Authorisation of trades:................................................................... 381 Credit enhancer and swap counterparty:..................................................... 381 Typical Credit enhancements in CDOs:........................................... 382 Subordination:........................................................................................................ 382 Cash collateral:...................................................................................................... 382 Excess spread:....................................................................................................... 383 Bond insurance or financial guarantee:......................................................... 383 Managing the assets of CDOs:................................................................... 383 Asset quality tests:..................................................................................... 384 Minimum average rating test:............................................................................ 384 Minimum recovery rate test:............................................................................. 384 Industry and obligor concentration tests:..................................................... 384 Minimum weighted average coupon:............................................................. 384 Cashflow coverage tests:........................................................................... 384 Over-collateralisation and interest coverage ratios:........................... 384 What happens when the tests are not met:....................................... 387 Cashflow waterfall:......................................................................... 387 Resecuritisation or structured finance cdos:................................................. 390 Growth of structured product CDOs:.............................................. 391 Distressed debt CDOs:.............................................................................. 392 What is distressed debt:.................................................................. 393 Distressed debt CDOs and securitisation of non-performing loans:... 393 Motivations:................................................................................... 394 Credit enhancement levels............................................................... 394 Typical issues in distressed debt CDOs:.......................................... 394 Evaluation of distressed debt CDO manager:................................... 395 Hedge fund CDOs or fund of funds............................................................ 396 Investing in CDOs:.................................................................................... 396 Investor motivations:....................................................................... 396 1. Strength and Stability..................................................................................... 397 2. Diversification................................................................................................... 397 3. Standardisation................................................................................................. 397 4. Deep market..................................................................................................... 397 5. Yield..................................................................................................................... 397 6. Transparency.................................................................................................... 397 Risks in CDO investment - structure and collateral risks:............................. 398 Interest rate and basis mismatch:..................................................... 398 Cross currency risk:........................................................................ 398 Liquidity risk:.................................................................................. 398 Ramp up risks:............................................................................... 399 Reinvestment risks during the revolving period:................................ 399 Asset risks:..................................................................................... 400 Taxation of CDOs:.................................................................................... 400 Legal issues specific to CDOs:................................................................... 401 Bankruptcy remoteness:.................................................................. 401 True sale opinion:........................................................................... 401 Transfer of loans and perfection:..................................................... 401 Right of set off:............................................................................... 403 Lender liability:............................................................................... 403 Current problems facing the CDO sector:................................................... 402 Increasing downgrades and defaults................................................ 403 Accounting worries:........................................................................ 404 De-leveraging:................................................................................ 404 chapter 12: Asset backed commercial paper............... 405 Genesis of asset backed commercial paper................................................ 406 The ABCP market.................................................................................... 407 Types of ABCP conduits:.......................................................................... 408 ABCP collateral:....................................................................................... 409 Structure of ABCP programs:.................................................................... 410 The role of the sponsor:.................................................................. 412 chapter 13: Future flows securitisation........................ 413 What future flows are securitisable:............................................................ 414 Some key features of future flows deals:.......................................... 414 Uncertain receivables:......................................................................................... 414 Cashflow trapping:............................................................................................... 414 Prioritisation of the transferee:......................................................................... 415 High extent of over-collateralisation:............................................................. 415 Restrictions on the borrower’s business:..................................................... 415 No originator independence:............................................................................ 415 Why future flow securitisation?................................................................... 416 Types of future flow deals :........................................................................ 417 Based on exports of goods or services........................................................ 417 Based on sales of goods or services............................................................. 418 Financial future flows........................................................................................... 418 Other future flows................................................................................................. 418 Structural features:..................................................................................... 418 Early amortization triggers:.............................................................. 418 Reps and warranties of the seller:.................................................... 419 The future flows market:............................................................................ 419 Legal taxation and accounting issues:.......................................................... 420 Experience with future flows:...................................................................... 421 chapter 14: Whole business and operating revenues securitisation 423 Market development................................................................................. 424 Methodology............................................................................................. 425 Secured loan structure.................................................................... 425 Bankruptcy protection:................................................................... 425 The legal basis:.......................................................................................... 427 Administrative receivership............................................................. 427 Law of receivership........................................................................ 428 Fixed and floating charges:.............................................................. 429 Challenge to floating charges: the ruling in Brumark's case:................ 429 UK Insolvency law amendment and whole business transactions:..... 430 Is a secured loan structure as safe as true sales?.............................. 431 Businesses where whole business securitisation is possible:......................... 431 Why SPV in a whole business structure:..................................................... 432 Inventory securitisation.............................................................................. 433 Case study: Rosey Blue diamond inventory securitisation................. 433 Potential products for inventory securitisation............................................. 434 chapter 15: Other miscellaneous asset classes......... 437 Securitisation of intellectual property:.......................................................... 437 Intellectual properties revenues securitisation market........................ 437 Music royalties:.............................................................................. 438 Bowie Bonds:......................................................................................................... 438 More instances of music securitisation:........................................................ 438 Transaction structure:.......................................................................................... 439 Film financing................................................................................. 440 Bond bonds................................................................................ 440 Dreamworks........................................................................................................... 440 Others:........................................................................................... 441 Securitization of non-performing loans........................................................ 441 The massive problem of bad loans:.................................................. 441 Resolution Trust Corp:.................................................................... 441 Models in other countries:............................................................... 442 Japan:........................................................................................................................ 442 MSDW’s securitization in Japan:................................................................... 442 Resolution and Collection Corp., Japan:..................................................... 443 Kamco’s Korean NPL securitisation............................................... 444 The NPL problem in Korea and initiatives to clean up:......................... 444 Kamco’s NPL sales and securitisation:....................................................... 445 The portfolio:.......................................................................................................... 445 The SPV structure................................................................................................ 446 The senior notes:................................................................................................... 446 Credit enhancements:.......................................................................................... 446 How does it actually happen:.......................................................... 446 Government receivables............................................................................. 447 Italian securitisations:...................................................................... 447 US tobacco settlement receivables:................................................. 448 chapter 16: Synthetic Securitisation and Other Risk Transfer Devices 451 Cash versus synthetic securitisation:............................................................ 452 Modus operandi:............................................................................ 453 Structured credit risk transfer:......................................................... 454 Leveraged risk transfer:.................................................................. 456 Super-senior swap............................................................................................... 457 Advantages of synthetic securitisation over cash transfers:........................... 458 Minimizes funding and reinvestment problems:......................................... 459 Splits the funding and the risk transfers........................................................ 459 Alleviates transfer-related problems:............................................................. 459 Does not require artificial separation of origination and servicing functions: 461 Lesser legal costs:................................................................................................. 462 No upfront taxation:............................................................................................. 462 Avoids double taxation of residual profits:.................................................. 463 No accounting volatility:..................................................................................... 463 Does not reduce book size:.............................................................................. 465 Retains flexibility in customer service:........................................................... 465 Distinction between cash-funded and synthetic securitisation:...................... 466 Elements of synthetic securitisation............................................................. 467 Originator:...................................................................................... 467 Obligor portfolio:............................................................................ 467 Type of Credit derivative:............................................................... 468 Credit events and loss computation:................................................ 468 Special purpose vehicle:.................................................................. 469 Assets of the SPV:......................................................................... 470 Liabilities of the SPV:..................................................................... 471 Non-SPV structures:...................................................................... 471 Sizing of the credit enhancement:..................................................... 472 Swap calculation agent:................................................................... 474 Trustees:........................................................................................ 474 Super senior swap provider:........................................................... 475 Other swap counterparties:............................................................. 475 Arbitrage synthetic CDOs:......................................................................... 475 Difference between arbitrage synthetic CDOs and balance sheet synthetic CDOs:…………….. 478 Collateral manager:......................................................................... 479 OC and IC triggers in case of synthetic CDOs:........................................... 479 Application of OC and IC triggers to synthetic CDOs:..................... 479 Paydown structure:.................................................................................... 480 Sequential paydown:....................................................................... 480 Pro-rata paydown:......................................................................... 480 Fast-pay/ slow-pay structure:.......................................................... 481 Evolution and growth of synthetic CDOs.................................................... 481 Investing in synthetic CDOs:...................................................................... 483 Insurance risk securitisation:....................................................................... 485 Alternative risk transfer:.................................................................. 486 Insurance securitisation:.................................................................. 486 Catastrophe bonds:.............................................................................................. 486 Not catastrophe risk securitisation................................................................. 486 Risk transfer by the insured.............................................................................. 487 The cat bonds market:.................................................................... 487 Illustration of the cat bonds technology:........................................... 489 Equity call option:........................................................................... 490 Insurance securitisation by non-insurance companies:....................... 490
Part III Technical Issues
chaper 17: LEGAL ISSUES IN SECURITISATION........................ 495 The significance of legal issues in securitisation:........................................... 496 Why are securitisation legal issues complicated?......................................... 497 What are the main legal issues?.................................................................. 498 Securitisation and loan obligations:............................................................. 498 The true sale question................................................................................ 501 Background of the true sale question:.............................................. 501 Why should we ask a true sale question?................................................... 501 Who can question the true sale?..................................................................... 501 What if it is not a true sale?............................................................................... 502 The question of substantive transfer or financing arrangement:.......... 502 Case law on true sale................................................................................. 502 US Cases....................................................................................... 504 Major's Furniture Mart:...................................................................................... 504 Evergreen Valley Resort:................................................................................... 506 Endico Potatoes:................................................................................................... 506 Octagon Gas:......................................................................................................... 507 LTV Steel:............................................................................................................... 508 Avianca future flow transaction:...................................................................... 509 UK cases:...................................................................................... 510 George Inglefield:.................................................................................................. 510 Other UK cases:................................................................................................... 511 Canadian ruling in BC Tel’s case:.................................................... 512 Safe harbour law:........................................................................... 513 The factors that make or mar a true sale:.................................................... 516 The role of language used by the parties:......................................... 516 Recourse:....................................................................................... 517 Residual interest:............................................................................. 518 Servicing by the seller:.................................................................... 519 Uncertain sale consideration:........................................................... 520 Factors in determination of a sale:.............................................................. 520 Requirements of valid transfer of receivables:................................... 520 Legal or legally enforceable transfer of the receivables:........................ 520 The receivables must be existing at the time of the assignment:.......... 521 The receivables must be identifiable.............................................................. 522 The whole of a receivable should be assigned:......................................... 522 The assignor must not be the assignee......................................................... 524 It must be an assignment of rights, not obligations:.................................. 524 There must not be contractual or other restrictions on transfer:......... 527 The rights must not be personal rights:......................................................... 527 There must not be a right of set-off or claims against the originator: 527 Methods of transferring receivables:........................................................... 527 Assignment:............................................................................................................. 527 Novation.................................................................................................................. 528 Sub-participation or participation:.................................................................. 528 Declaration of trust:.............................................................................................. 529 Legal procedure for assignment of receivables:........................................... 529 English common law:...................................................................... 529 Roman-Dutch law or Civil law........................................................ 530 Procedure for assignment of actionable claims:........................................... 531 Meaning of debt or actionable claims:.............................................. 532 Instrument in writing:............................................................................................ 533 Obligor notification:.............................................................................................. 534 Cases where conveyance or obligor notification not required:........... 535 Mode of transfer of actionable claims:......................................................... 536 Equitable assignment:................................................................................. 537 What is equitable assignment:.......................................................... 537 Why equitable assignment:.............................................................. 538 Problems with equitable assignment:................................................ 539 Stamp duty on securitisation: general:......................................................... 540 FAQs on stamp duty on securitisation:............................................ 540 Why applicable to securitisation transaction?............................................ 540 What attracts the duty - the transaction or the instrument?.................. 540 What is the chargeable amount for duty purposes?................................ 540 What are the common ways to avoid the duty?....................................... 541 Can the duty be avoided by oral agreements?.......................................... 541 Can the duty be applicable to agreements electronically signed and stored?……………….. 542 What is the duty applicable to revolving asset securitisation?............. 542 What is the duty applicable to future receivables securitisation?........ 542 Is the duty applicable to transfer of pass-through securities?.............. 542 Is there any duty on issue of pass through certificates?......................... 543 Avoiding stamp duty by shifting jurisdiction:................................................ 543 Situation of "receivables"................................................................. 544 Position in case of multi-State properties:........................................ 544 Stamp duties on transfer of investors’ interest:............................................ 545 Beneficial interest versus equitable interest................................................. 545 Legal nature of investors’ right in case of securitisations:...................... 546 Stamp duty on securitisation transactions: Indian case................................. 547 Reduction of stamp duty by Maharashtra:........................................ 547 Other states follow:......................................................................... 548 Lessons from India:........................................................................ 548 Stamp duty relaxations in other countries.................................................... 549 Malaysia:........................................................................................ 550 Australia......................................................................................... 551 Secured loan structures:............................................................................. 552 Legal issues in synthetic structures.............................................................. 556 Bankruptcy remote securitisation................................................................ 556 Perfection of legal interest:................................................................................ 557 Priority of claims:.................................................................................................. 557 Protecting against consolidation:..................................................................... 558 Protecting against clawback:............................................................................ 558 Structuring the SPV:.................................................................................. 559 Why SPV:...................................................................................... 559 Legal considerations:...................................................................... 560 Organisational forms of SPVs:................................................................... 560 Corporations:................................................................................. 560 Trusts:............................................................................................ 561 What is a trust:....................................................................................................... 561 Trusts and securitisation:.................................................................................... 561 LLCs:........................................................................................................................ 562 Special forms:......................................................................................................... 562 Bankruptcy remoteness of SPVs:............................................................... 562 Conditions for bankruptcy-remoteness:........................................... 563 Restriction on Objects and Powers............................................................... 563 Debt Limitations.................................................................................................... 563 Non-petition agreement:.................................................................................... 564 The Independent Director................................................................................. 564 No Merger or Reorganization......................................................................... 565 Separateness Covenants.................................................................................... 565 No free-floating assets, no net worth............................................................ 566 Limitations in constitutional documents:............................................ 566 Ownership structure of the SPV:..................................................... 567 Multi-use SPVs:............................................................................. 567 Consolidation of the SPV:.......................................................................... 568 Meaning of equitable consolidation:.............................................................. 568 General principles of consolidation:............................................................... 568 Buckhead America ruling.................................................................................. 569 Kingston Square:.................................................................................................. 569 Legal rights of the investor: legal nature of the investor's right:...................... 570 Investor's rights against the originator:.......................................................... 570 Investor's rights against the SPV:................................................................... 570 Investor's rights against the obligors:............................................................. 571 Investor's rights as holders of "security"....................................................... 572 Legal nature of a future flow securitisation:.................................................. 573 Assignability of future flows:............................................................ 574 General rule:............................................................................................................ 574 Common law:......................................................................................................... 574 Other countries:..................................................................................................... 575 Structuring future flows:.................................................................. 575 Ideal legal framework for securitisation:..................................................... 576 UNCTRAL initiative for uniform law on assignment of receivables.............. 578 Appendix 1 Model legal opinion for a securitisation transaction 579 Appendix 2 UNCITRAL CONVENTION.......................................... 583 Appendix 3 Provisions of the Indian Transfer of Property Act 605 appendx 4: Stamp notifications in India........................... 608 Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957...................................................................... 608 Bombay Stamp Act................................................................................... 608 Bombay Stamps Act, 1958 (As applicable to the State of Gujarat)............. 609 Tamil Nadu: Indian Stamp Act, 1899......................................................... 609 West Bengal:............................................................................................. 610 chapter 18: Legal documentation for securitisation 611 Basic structure of documentation:............................................................... 612 The pooling and servicing agreement:......................................................... 612 Identification of asset to be assigned:............................................... 613 How is the identification of receivables done:............................................ 613 Samples :.................................................................................................................. 614 Conveyance clause:........................................................................ 617 Registration, stamping, etc:............................................................................... 617 Restrictions on re-transfer, etc:....................................................................... 617 Transfer of rights, not obligations:.................................................................. 617 Any continuing or future transfers:.................................................................. 618 Contingency of the transfer not being regarded as true sale:............... 618 Consideration for the transfer:......................................................... 618 Conditions precedent:..................................................................... 619 Representations and warranties of the Seller:................................... 619 Standard representations about the Seller:................................................. 620 Standard representations about the Receivables:..................................... 621 Specific representations about the Receivables:......................... | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||